Monday, 30 April 2018

P1 - Tabloid Vs Broadsheet on the Same News Story

Comparison of the Same Story in Two Different News Articles

The Telegraph



In the Telegraph when talking about ‘Brexit’ the writer often makes it seem like the Brexit negotiations are making the UK look weak. For example they describe Britain as being left as the European Union’s “Lackey” suggesting that the UK is being dragged around by Brussels and Germany and being made a fool of.
Another Example is that they ask for Jacob Reese-Moggs’ opinion as he has been appointed as the newly elected chair of the influential European Research Group of Eurosceptic Tory MPs. Jacob Reese-Mogg suggests that the UK would become a “vassal state” of the EU.
Overall the Telegraph has a negative view of the Brexit Negotiations that are occurring and want to get out of the EU as quickly as possible, this is a more right wing view as most brexiteers want stricter border control and less continental opinions.
This shows that there is bias towards certain politics and political stances in the newspapers/print media which can be interpreted. The telegraph is a conservative paper so its views come across as conservative. Even on Wikipedia the paper is described as a conservative paper. Sometimes being referred to as the ‘Torygraph’ showing that people know that the paper is more right leaning.


The Mirror






On the other hand the Mirror approaches with a more optimistic outlook on the Brexit negotiations suggesting that the longer negotiations are a better way of getting out of the EU. The article says that “The influential figures tonight said they believe the UK is heading for a Norway-style relationship with Brussels during a transition period of around two years immediately after March 2019.” This view is a more optimistic view than being called a “Lackey” this comparison towards Norway is a positive for the extended length negotiations as Norway, although not being in the EU have access to trade deals and easy access to the other EU nations.
Belgian MEP Philippe Lamberts told The Independent: "During the transition period, the UK will be a member in all but name, but it will no longer sit at the two tables where decisions are made; parliament and council. This sugar coats the fact that the UK is not in control of what decisions will be made about our Brexit and the deals that we get with Brussels and the rest of the EU after we leave.
The Mirror goes for a more liberal and Pro-Brexit negotiations taking a longer time as that is a more liberal view, which is what the paper describes itself as.
In conclusion it is apparent that different papers have a political opinion and that their articles reflect these opinions within the articles identifiable by the word choice and the language used. E.g. the Mirror tend to make the problems with staying in the EU lesser than leaving and vice versa for the telegraph complaining that the faster we get out the better we will do.


No comments:

Post a Comment